Ontario Teacher Answers
Assessment & Evaluation
The difference between assessment for, as and of learning, and how evidence becomes a defensible grade.
Answers in this domain
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What is triangulation of evidence in Ontario assessment?
Triangulation means a teacher's evaluation rests on evidence gathered from three sources — observations of students working, conversations with students about their thinking, and student products. In Ontario this comes from Growing Success, which states that evidence of student achievement for evaluation is collected over time from all three sources. It is not a checklist. Triangulation does not require exactly one observation, one conversation and one product for every expectation. It means the picture you form of a student's achievement is not built on marked work alone, because a single product can hide what a student understands and can misrepresent students who struggle to show learning in writing.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What is Growing Success in Ontario?
Growing Success is the Ontario Ministry of Education policy document that governs assessment, evaluation and reporting in publicly funded schools for Grades 1 to 12. It sets out the principles of fair assessment, distinguishes assessment for, as and of learning, requires evidence to be gathered from observations, conversations and student products, and establishes the role of professional judgement in determining a grade. It also defines the Achievement Chart categories and levels, the learning skills and work habits reported separately from achievement, and the reporting cycle. A Kindergarten Addendum extends the policy to the Kindergarten program. Growing Success is the framework; boards and schools add local procedure within it.
- What's requiredGrades 1–12
Is Growing Success still in effect in Ontario in 2026?
Yes. As of the last verification date shown on this page, Growing Success (2010) remains the Ontario Ministry of Education's assessment, evaluation and reporting policy for Grades 1 to 12, and the Kindergarten Addendum (2016) remains in effect for Kindergarten. It has not been withdrawn or replaced. Individual elements of Ontario assessment practice do change around it — curriculum documents are revised, Policy/Program Memoranda are issued, and boards update their own procedures — so a specific practice may be governed by a newer document even while Growing Success itself still stands. Because this is a policy-status question, this page is re-checked against the Ministry source on a short cycle.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What is the Ontario Achievement Chart?
The Achievement Chart is the provincial standard for judging the quality of student work. Each Ontario curriculum document contains its own subject-specific version, organized into four categories: Knowledge and Understanding, Thinking, Communication, and Application. Within each category, four levels describe how effectively a student demonstrates the knowledge and skills, with Level 3 representing the provincial standard. Levels are defined by descriptors of quality — limited, some, considerable and a high degree of effectiveness — not by arithmetic. The chart is used to plan assessment, to build rubrics and to arrive at a professional judgement about achievement of the curriculum expectations.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What do Knowledge, Thinking, Communication and Application mean in Ontario assessment?
They are the four categories of knowledge and skills in the Ontario Achievement Chart. Knowledge and Understanding covers subject-specific content and comprehension of its meaning. Thinking covers the use of critical and creative thinking skills and processes — planning, investigating, reasoning. Communication covers the conveying of meaning and the expression and organization of ideas for different audiences and purposes. Application covers the use and transfer of knowledge and skills to familiar and new contexts. Every Ontario curriculum document defines these categories in subject-specific language. A single task does not have to assess all four, and the categories do not have to be weighted equally.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What is descriptive feedback in Ontario assessment?
Descriptive feedback tells a student where their work stands in relation to the learning goal and success criteria, and what to do next. It describes the evidence in the work rather than judging the student, and it arrives while there is still time to act on it. In Ontario this sits inside assessment for learning and assessment as learning: feedback given for the purpose of improving learning is not used to determine a grade. Feedback becomes descriptive when it names the criterion, points to the specific evidence, and identifies one next action the student can take.
- What's requiredGrades 1–12
Can behaviour affect a student's academic grade in Ontario?
No. In Ontario, a subject grade reports achievement of the curriculum expectations and nothing else. Behaviour, effort, attitude, participation for its own sake and meeting timelines are learning skills and work habits, and Growing Success requires them to be reported separately from achievement, using the scale Excellent, Good, Satisfactory, Needs Improvement. That separation is the whole point: a parent reading the report should be able to see that a student understands the mathematics and still struggles to submit it. Behaviour can legitimately affect a grade only indirectly, when it prevents the student from producing evidence you can assess — and then the professional response is to find another route to the evidence, not to lower the mark. Boards and schools set local procedures for documenting behaviour and for progressive discipline.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
What is the difference between assessment for, as and of learning?
Assessment for learning happens during learning: the teacher gathers evidence to find out where students are and adjusts instruction and feedback accordingly. Assessment as learning also happens during learning, but the student is the assessor — reflecting, self-monitoring and setting goals against success criteria. Assessment of learning happens at or near the end of a cycle and is used to evaluate achievement and determine a grade. In Ontario, evidence for evaluation is gathered from three sources — observations, conversations and student products — which is often called triangulation. Only assessment of learning is evaluated for a grade; the other two inform teaching and learning.
- How toGrades 1–8
How do I create a diagnostic assessment in Ontario?
A diagnostic assessment is given before instruction to find out what students already know and can do, so that planning starts from evidence rather than assumption. In Ontario it is not evaluated and does not contribute to a grade. Good diagnostics are short, target the prerequisite skills for the coming unit, and produce information you can group by. Useful formats include a three-question open task, a sorting activity, a short conference prompt, or an entry ticket tied to one overall expectation. Plan what you will do with each likely result before you administer it — a diagnostic that does not change your first week of teaching was not worth the period.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
How does the Ontario Achievement Chart work in a rubric?
The Ontario Achievement Chart organizes assessment into four categories — Knowledge and Understanding, Thinking, Communication, and Application — and four levels of achievement. Level 3 is the provincial standard; Level 4 indicates achievement above the standard, Level 2 approaching it, and Level 1 achievement that falls much below. Levels are distinguished by descriptors of effectiveness such as limited, some, considerable and a high degree, applied to the same criterion. A workable rubric names the criterion in student language, uses the four categories as its rows, and changes only the qualifier across the columns — not the task.
- What's requiredGrades 1–12
How should late and missing work be handled in Ontario?
Ontario policy expects late and missing work to be handled first as a learning and behaviour problem, using prevention and a range of responses, before any mark is affected. Growing Success is explicit that a deduction of marks for lateness is one possible response, applied with professional judgement, and that a grade must still reflect the student's most consistent achievement of the curriculum expectations. That is why an automatic zero for unsubmitted work is difficult to defend: it reports the absence of evidence as an achievement level. Habits such as meeting timelines belong in the learning skills and work habits section of the report card, not in the subject grade. Boards and schools set the local procedure, so check your school's assessment policy before you set your own.
- What's requiredGrades 1–12
Can Ontario teachers average marks to determine a grade?
A grade in Ontario is determined by professional judgement, not by arithmetic alone. Growing Success directs teachers to consider the student's most consistent level of achievement, with special consideration for the more recent evidence, so a straight average of every mark in the gradebook is not the policy standard. Calculation still has a role: your marks are the evidence base, and most boards run a gradebook that computes a number. What matters is that the number you report matches your professional judgement of consistent achievement against the curriculum expectations, and that you can explain the decision from the evidence. Where recent work clearly demonstrates a higher level than earlier attempts, the reported grade should reflect that growth.
- How toGrades 1–12
How does moderated marking work in an Ontario school?
Moderated marking is a team of teachers assessing the same student work against the same criteria and then reconciling the differences. In Ontario it is a professional practice rather than a legislated requirement: Growing Success requires that evaluation be based on the achievement chart and on consistent professional judgement, and moderation is how a team builds that consistency. A workable session has four parts — agree on the expectation and criteria before looking at work, mark independently, compare and discuss only the pieces where the team disagrees, then record the agreed anchors. The output is a small set of exemplars the team can point to in November when the same debate returns. Release time, scheduling and whether moderation is a board expectation are local decisions.
- What's requiredGrades 1–8
How do I assess and report for English language learners?
Assessment for English language learners has to separate language proficiency from subject knowledge. Accommodations and, where required, modified expectations are used so that assessment measures the curriculum learning rather than English fluency, and the ESL/ELD box on the report card is checked when the program is adapted. When expectations are modified for language reasons, the report card comment explains that the grade reflects those adapted expectations. Proficiency itself is tracked with the STEP continua rather than with subject grades, and it moves independently of achievement. Boards decide the identification and initial assessment procedure, which STEP recording tools are used and how ELL supports are staffed, so the operational detail comes from your board's ESL/ELD procedure rather than from the province.
- How toKindergarten–Grade 12
What should I look for in the OSR before I plan for September?
The Ontario Student Record follows a student from school to school and contains the documents a principal is required to place in it, including report cards, any IEP, and documentation of a Provincial Assessment result. Before planning your first units, read last year's report card comments and learning skills ratings, note whether a student has an active IEP or is going through an identification process, and check for documented accommodations already in place. The OSR tells you what has already been tried and reported; it is a starting point for diagnostic assessment, not a substitute for it. Confirm your board's procedure for OSR access and timing — folders may not be transferred to the classroom until the first days of school, and some boards route special education information through a resource teacher first.
- What's requiredGrades 1–12
Does diagnostic assessment count toward a report card grade in Ontario?
No. Diagnostic assessment is given before or at the start of instruction to find out what a student already knows and can do, and Growing Success is explicit that it is used to inform program planning, not to determine a grade. Policy/Program Memorandum 155 sets out that diagnostic assessment supports student learning by identifying strengths and areas for growth so instruction can be adjusted — again, a planning purpose rather than an evaluative one. If a September task produces a score you are tempted to enter as a mark, ask what instructional purpose it served: if the answer is 'to find out where students are starting from', it stays out of the gradebook, however well a student performed on it. Evaluation happens later, once students have had instruction and the chance to improve, using evidence of achievement of curriculum expectations.
- ExplanationGrades 1–12
How much evidence is enough to determine an Ontario report card grade?
Growing Success sets no minimum number of assessments. Evidence is sufficient when you have enough recent, varied evidence — gathered through observation, conversation and student products — to make a confident judgement about each overall expectation you are reporting on. If you cannot make that judgement, the answer is to gather more evidence, not to average what you have.
- ExplanationGrades 1 to 12
What does 'most recent and most consistent' mean in Ontario assessment?
It means a grade reflects where a student's achievement has settled, not an average of everything they produced. You weigh the most recent evidence more heavily because learning improves, and you look for the level the student demonstrates most consistently. Where recency and consistency disagree, professional judgement decides, and the reason is recorded.
- What's requiredGrades 1 to 12
Do Ontario teachers have to allow redos and retakes?
No Ontario policy document sets a province-wide rule entitling every student to a retake. Growing Success does expect assessment to support improvement and grades to reflect the most recent and most consistent achievement, which makes second attempts professionally appropriate in many cases. The details are school and board practice, and your professional judgement.
- ExplanationGrades 1 to 12
What does professional judgement mean in Ontario assessment?
Professional judgement in Ontario is judgement informed by professional knowledge of curriculum expectations, context, evidence of learning and assessment methods. It is not personal preference and it is not a way around evidence. It is how you decide what the body of evidence shows when the numbers alone do not decide it for you.
- ExplanationGrades 1 to 12
How do Ontario achievement levels relate to percentage marks?
Ontario uses four levels of achievement, each mapped to a percentage range: level 1 is 50–59, level 2 is 60–69, level 3 is 70–79 and level 4 is 80–100. Level 3 is the provincial standard. Below 50 per cent indicates achievement below level 1. The level comes first; the percentage expresses it.
- ComparisonGrades 1 to 12
When should I use a rubric instead of a checklist?
Use a checklist when the criteria are present or absent — the citation is there or it is not. Use a rubric when quality varies along a continuum and you need to describe how well, not whether. Checklists suit success criteria and process steps; rubrics suit evaluation against the achievement chart categories.
- ExplanationGrades 1 to 12
How do self-assessment and peer assessment fit Ontario assessment policy?
Self-assessment and peer assessment are assessment as learning: students monitor their own progress against criteria and set next steps. They build metacognition and they inform your teaching, but the grade rests on your evaluation of the student's achievement. Student-generated judgements are not the evidence a report card mark is built from.
- What's requiredGrades 9 to 12
What is the 30 per cent final evaluation in Ontario secondary courses?
In Grades 9 to 12, seventy per cent of the final grade comes from evaluation conducted throughout the course, and thirty per cent comes from a final evaluation administered at or near the end. The final evaluation can be an examination, a performance task, an essay, or a combination — it does not have to be a written exam.
- What's requiredKindergarten to Grade 12
Does Ontario have a homework policy?
Ontario does not set a province-wide homework policy or a maximum number of minutes. School boards set homework policies, and schools interpret them. What provincial policy does set is where the grade comes from: achievement of the curriculum expectations, demonstrated in evidence you have judged.
- What's requiredGrades 1 to 12
Can I give a group mark in Ontario?
Group work is excellent instruction, but the reported grade has to represent each student's own achievement of the curriculum expectations. Assess the individual contribution and each student's individual demonstration of the learning. Collaboration itself is reported through the learning skills, not through the subject grade.
- How toGrades 1 to 12
How should Ontario teachers respond to cheating or plagiarism?
Start with a conversation, not a penalty. Ontario policy directs teachers to consider the grade level, the maturity of the student, the number and frequency of incidents, and the individual circumstances before deciding a response. The consequence itself comes from your board's policy, and the mark still has to reflect achievement.