Skip to content
    How toGrades 1–12· Reviewed annually

    How does moderated marking work in an Ontario school?

    Run or take part in a moderation session that actually changes how the team marks.

    Ontario source-backedLast verified Next review

    Short answer

    How does moderated marking work in an Ontario school?

    Moderated marking is a team of teachers assessing the same student work against the same criteria and then reconciling the differences. In Ontario it is a professional practice rather than a legislated requirement: Growing Success requires that evaluation be based on the achievement chart and on consistent professional judgement, and moderation is how a team builds that consistency. A workable session has four parts — agree on the expectation and criteria before looking at work, mark independently, compare and discuss only the pieces where the team disagrees, then record the agreed anchors. The output is a small set of exemplars the team can point to in November when the same debate returns. Release time, scheduling and whether moderation is a board expectation are local decisions.

    Ontario context

    • Growing Success grounds evaluation in the achievement chart and in consistent professional judgement, which is what moderation is protecting.
    • Moderation is a professional practice, not a compliance requirement — no policy prescribes a session format.
    • The valuable output is the set of anchor pieces, not the marks assigned during the session.
    • Whether moderation is scheduled, funded or expected is a board and school decision.

    What is actually required

    Ontario policy
    • Evaluation is based on the achievement chart categories and on the teacher's professional judgement applied consistently.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • The levels of achievement describe the same quality of work across classrooms, which is what a moderation session is checking.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • Scheduling, release time and any expectation to moderate are set locally by the board or school.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

      Your board or school may have additional procedures.

    What strong practice looks like

    Professional practice
    • Anonymize the work before the session — names shift judgement more than teams expect.
    • Mark independently first. A discussion that begins before independent marking produces agreement without accuracy.
    • Spend the time on the disagreements, not on the pieces everyone placed at the same level.

    What this looks like in practice

    Session structure

    Instead of: Team meets and discusses marks for an hour.

    10 minutes on the expectation and criteria, 15 minutes independent marking of six anonymized pieces, 15 minutes on the two pieces with the widest spread, 5 minutes to select and label anchors.

    Why it works: Independent judgement is captured before discussion, and the time goes to the cases that actually reveal the disagreement.

    What gets recorded

    One anchor per level with a two-line note explaining the placement, stored in the shared grade-team folder and revisited before the next reporting period.

    Try it: plan a moderation session

    Choose the division and the focus. You will get a session outline with timings. No student information.

    Choose every option to see the sample structures.

    Practical suggestions

    Practical classroom suggestion
    • Six to eight pieces is enough for a 45-minute session; twenty pieces produces a rushed sort rather than a discussion.
    • Keep one anchor per level, photographed and stored where the team can find it in reporting season.
    • End by naming one change each teacher will make to the task or the criteria — otherwise the session stays theoretical.

    Common mistakes

    Discussing before marking independently.

    Instead: Mark alone first, then compare.

    Trying to moderate everything.

    Instead: Moderate one task per term, deeply.

    Leaving with agreement but no artifacts.

    Instead: Record anchors and the reasoning behind each placement.

    From Ontario practice

    Reviewed practical insight from Ontario classroom and school leadership experience.

    • Teams usually agree on Level 4 and Level 1 quickly; the real work is the boundary between Level 2 and Level 3.
    • The anchor set is what makes the next reporting period faster — moderation pays off a term later, not the same week.

    Different lenses

    Teacher lens

    Independent marking first is the single rule that makes a session worth the release time.

    School leadership lens

    Ask for the anchor set, not the meeting minutes — anchors are the evidence a session worked.

    Go deeper

    Ontario sources

    Every source we cite, with its verification date, is listed in the public source index.

    Was this answer helpful?

    Prepared by Ontario Curriculum AI.

    Last reviewed 2026-08-17 · next review 2027-02-17

    Ontario Curriculum AI supports professional work. Educators retain professional judgement for all assessment, evaluation and reporting decisions.