Skip to content
    ExplanationGrades 1 to 12· Reviewed annually

    How do self-assessment and peer assessment fit Ontario assessment policy?

    Use self- and peer-assessment to build metacognition without letting it produce the grade.

    Ontario source-backedLast verified Next review

    Short answer

    How do self-assessment and peer assessment fit Ontario assessment policy?

    Self-assessment and peer assessment are assessment as learning: students monitor their own progress against criteria and set next steps. They build metacognition and they inform your teaching, but the grade rests on your evaluation of the student's achievement. Student-generated judgements are not the evidence a report card mark is built from.

    Ontario context

    • Ontario names three purposes of assessment — for learning, as learning, and of learning. Self- and peer-assessment sit squarely in the second.
    • Assessment as learning is where students develop the capacity to set goals, monitor progress and adjust — an explicit aim of the policy, not an add-on.
    • Evaluation of achievement remains the teacher's professional responsibility.
    • Peer feedback is about the work against criteria. It is not peer marking, and it works only where the criteria are concrete.

    What is actually required

    Ontario policy
    • Growing Success requires that the evaluation of student achievement, and the grade reported, be determined by the teacher rather than by students.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation, and Reporting in Ontario Schools (2010)

    • Growing Success identifies assessment as learning, in which students monitor their own progress against criteria, as one of the three purposes of classroom assessment.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation, and Reporting in Ontario Schools (2010)

    Making self-assessment worth the minutes

    • Give students the same criteria you will use, in the same words.
    • Ask for evidence, not a rating: 'point to the sentence where you did this' beats a checkbox.
    • Follow it with a next step the student chooses and you confirm. Self-assessment without a next step is a survey.
    • Compare their judgement to yours occasionally and talk about the gap — that conversation is the learning.

    Peer feedback that is not vague praise

    • Restrict it to one criterion at a time. 'Find the strongest piece of evidence and say why' produces usable feedback.
    • Model it once with a sample piece, including a weak example, before students do it.
    • Give sentence starters. Feedback quality tracks language scaffolding almost exactly.

    What strong practice looks like

    Professional practice
    • Use the pattern of student self-assessments as diagnostic information: where students systematically overrate, the criteria are not yet clear.
    • Keep peer feedback formative and unrecorded in your mark book.
    • Teach the vocabulary of the achievement chart so students can describe quality rather than guess at it.

    What this looks like in practice

    A Grade 5 writing conference

    Instead of: Ask students to circle a face and hand in the sheet.

    Ask them to highlight the sentence that best meets the criterion, explain the choice in one line, and name one improvement for the next draft.

    Why it works: The task asks the student to apply the criteria to their own work, which is the point of assessment as learning.

    Grade 9 peer review of a lab conclusion

    One criterion, two sentence starters, five minutes, then the writer names what they will change.

    Why it works: Narrow scope and modelled language produce feedback the writer can act on.

    Practical suggestions

    Practical classroom suggestion
    • Two questions is enough: what does this show, and what will you change next time?
    • Colour-code criteria in the student's own draft rather than using a separate sheet.
    • Rotate peer partners so feedback does not become a friendship transaction.

    Common mistakes

    Averaging peer marks into the grade.

    Instead: Keep peer work formative; evaluation of achievement stays with you.

    Using self-assessment as an attendance-style routine.

    Instead: Tie it to specific criteria and a next step, or drop it and use the time to teach.

    Assuming students can assess without being taught how.

    Instead: Model with samples and give language scaffolds first.

    The takeaway

    Self- and peer-assessment develop the student's capacity to judge their own work against criteria. They shape teaching and next steps — they do not produce the grade.

    Ontario sources

    Every source we cite, with its verification date, is listed in the public source index.

    Was this answer helpful?

    Prepared by Ontario Curriculum AI.

    Last reviewed 2026-08-19 · next review 2027-02-19

    Ontario Curriculum AI supports professional work. Educators retain professional judgement for all assessment, evaluation and reporting decisions.