Skip to content
    ExplanationGrades 1–12· Reviewed annually

    How much evidence is enough to determine an Ontario report card grade?

    Decide whether you can defensibly evaluate a student this reporting period.

    Ontario source-backedLast verified Next review

    Short answer

    How much evidence is enough to determine an Ontario report card grade?

    Growing Success sets no minimum number of assessments. Evidence is sufficient when you have enough recent, varied evidence — gathered through observation, conversation and student products — to make a confident judgement about each overall expectation you are reporting on. If you cannot make that judgement, the answer is to gather more evidence, not to average what you have.

    Ontario context

    • Growing Success frames evaluation as professional judgement applied to evidence, not as a calculation performed on a spreadsheet.
    • Evidence is gathered from three sources — observations, conversations and student products — and the balance among them is a professional decision.
    • A grade reflects the student's most consistent level of achievement, with special consideration for more recent evidence, which is a statement about the shape of your evidence set.
    • The 'I' code exists for genuinely insufficient evidence, and using it well is a professional act, not an admission of failure.

    What is actually required

    Ontario policy
    • Evaluation is based on evidence of learning gathered from observations, conversations and student products.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • The determination of a grade involves professional judgement and interpretation of evidence; it is not a purely mechanical calculation.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • The grade reflects the student's most consistent level of achievement, with special consideration given to more recent evidence.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • 'I' may be used on the report card where there is insufficient evidence to determine a letter grade or percentage mark, in the circumstances Growing Success describes.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

    • Local procedures for approving the use of 'I', and for documenting evidence, are set by schools and boards.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation and Reporting in Ontario Schools, First Edition, Covering Grades 1 to 12

      Your board or school may have additional procedures.

    There is no magic number

    • No Ontario policy document states a minimum number of assessments per strand, per term or per expectation. Any number you have been given — three per strand, one per week — is a school or board convention, and it is worth knowing which.
    • A convention can be useful; it is not the standard. The standard is whether you can defend a judgement about each overall expectation you are reporting.

    What sufficiency actually depends on

    • Coverage: do you have evidence for each overall expectation you are reporting on, rather than three pieces on the same one?
    • Recency: does your evidence describe the student as they are now, or as they were in September?
    • Variety: have you seen the skill through more than one channel — a conversation as well as a written product?
    • Consistency: does the evidence tell a stable story, or is it one strong task and one absence?
    • Conditions: was the evidence gathered under conditions that let this student show what they know?

    When evidence is genuinely insufficient

    • Extended absence, a very late enrolment, or a student who has not produced assessable work despite repeated opportunities are the real cases.
    • A missed unit test is not one of them. A missed task is a gap you can close with a different task.
    • Before reaching for 'I', try the cheapest evidence first: a five-minute conference, a short performance task, or an observation against the same success criteria.

    What to do before you reach for 'I'

    • Check what you already have. Anecdotal notes and conference records are evidence, even if they are not in the mark book.
    • Offer one more opportunity in a form the student can actually complete, and record the date you offered it.
    • Talk to your principal early — the use of 'I' usually involves a school-level conversation, and leaving it to submission day removes everyone's options.
    • If the principal does not agree that 'I' is appropriate, that is a local decision about the report card entry, and it does not change the standard: you still need evidence you can defend. Ask what evidence would satisfy the concern, gather one more targeted piece against the same overall expectation, and record what was offered and when. Evaluate on the evidence you end up with, not on the pressure of the deadline.

    Judging whether your evidence is sufficient

    Coverage

    Sufficient
    Evidence for each overall expectation being reported
    Not yet sufficient
    Several pieces on one expectation, nothing on another

    Recency

    Sufficient
    Includes work from the last few weeks of the period
    Not yet sufficient
    Newest evidence is two months old

    Variety

    Sufficient
    At least two of observation, conversation and product
    Not yet sufficient
    Written products only, for a student who struggles to write

    Consistency

    Sufficient
    A stable pattern you could describe to a parent
    Not yet sufficient
    One strong task and one blank

    A judgement aid, not a policy checklist. Growing Success requires professional judgement, not a score on this table.

    What strong practice looks like

    Professional practice
    • Plan evidence at the same time as the unit. If you can name where each overall expectation will be assessed before you teach it, sufficiency mostly takes care of itself.
    • Record conversations. A dated conference note is admissible evidence and often the fastest way to close a gap for a student who does not produce written work.
    • When evidence conflicts, weight the most recent and the most consistent, and write down why you did.

    What this looks like in practice

    A Grade 6 student with strong conversations and thin written work in mathematics

    Instead of: Grade the two written tasks you have and note that work was incomplete.

    Add a short problem-solving conference against the same success criteria, record the observation, and evaluate the overall expectation on the fuller evidence set.

    Why it works: Growing Success treats conversations and observations as evidence in their own right; restricting yourself to products can understate achievement.

    A Grade 3 student who enrolled in May

    Gather what is available, speak with the principal about whether 'I' is appropriate for any strand, and document the opportunities offered.

    Why it works: This is the circumstance the 'I' code exists for — genuinely insufficient evidence, not missing work.

    Practical suggestions

    Practical classroom suggestion
    • Two weeks out from the deadline, scan for blanks by expectation, not by student — the gaps cluster.
    • Keep one column in your mark book for 'evidence type' so you can see at a glance where you have only products.
    • If you find yourself averaging to avoid a judgement call, that is the signal to gather one more piece of evidence.

    Common mistakes

    Treating a board or division guideline as a provincial minimum.

    Instead: Follow the local guideline, but know that Growing Success sets no number and your judgement is the standard.

    Using 'I' as a consequence for missing work.

    Instead: Deal with missing work through your school's late and missing work procedures; reserve 'I' for genuinely insufficient evidence.

    Filling a gap by averaging in an unrelated task.

    Instead: Gather one targeted piece of evidence for the expectation that is thin.

    The takeaway

    Sufficiency is a judgement about whether you can describe each overall expectation confidently, not a count. If you could not explain your grade to a parent using the evidence in front of you, you need one more piece — not a different formula.

    Ontario sources

    Every source we cite, with its verification date, is listed in the public source index.

    Was this answer helpful?

    Prepared by Ontario Curriculum AI.

    Last reviewed 2026-08-18 · next review 2027-08-18

    Ontario Curriculum AI supports professional work. Educators retain professional judgement for all assessment, evaluation and reporting decisions.