Skip to content
    ExplanationGrades 1 to 12· Reviewed annually

    What does professional judgement mean in Ontario assessment?

    Use professional judgement the way Ontario policy means it, and be able to explain the decision.

    Ontario source-backedLast verified Next review

    Short answer

    What does professional judgement mean in Ontario assessment?

    Professional judgement in Ontario is judgement informed by professional knowledge of curriculum expectations, context, evidence of learning and assessment methods. It is not personal preference and it is not a way around evidence. It is how you decide what the body of evidence shows when the numbers alone do not decide it for you.

    Ontario context

    • Growing Success uses professional judgement as a defined term, tied to curriculum expectations, evidence and the teacher's knowledge of the student — not to instinct.
    • It is exercised most visibly at reporting time, when a teacher determines the grade that best represents a student's achievement of the overall expectations.
    • It works in both directions: it can raise a mark that an arithmetic mean understates, and it can withhold a grade where the evidence is insufficient.
    • It is individual but not private. A judgement you cannot explain in terms of the expectations and the evidence is not the kind of judgement the policy describes.

    What is actually required

    Ontario policy
    • Growing Success defines professional judgement as judgement informed by professional knowledge of curriculum expectations, context, evidence of learning, methods of instruction and assessment, and the criteria and standards that indicate success in student learning.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation, and Reporting in Ontario Schools (2010)

    • Growing Success states that the report card grade represents a student's achievement of overall curriculum expectations, determined using the teacher's professional judgement rather than a simple calculation alone.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation, and Reporting in Ontario Schools (2010)

    What it licenses

    • Weighting more recent, more consistent evidence over an early attempt on the same expectations.
    • Deciding that a single very low outlier does not represent achievement of the overall expectation.
    • Choosing which of two assessment tools produced the more valid evidence for a particular student.
    • Determining that the evidence you hold is not yet enough to evaluate, and saying so.

    What it does not license

    • Adjusting a grade for behaviour, effort, attendance or attitude, which are reported through learning skills.
    • Replacing evidence with impression, or grading the student you know rather than the work you have.
    • A decision you would not be comfortable explaining, in writing, to the student's family and your principal.

    Judgement or preference?

    Most recent consistent work outweighs September's first attempt

    Which one
    Judgement
    Why
    Growth on the same expectations is evidence about the same learning

    Bump a mark because the student tried hard

    Which one
    Preference
    Why
    Effort is reported through learning skills

    Drop the lowest score without a reason

    Which one
    Preference
    Why
    No basis in the evidence or the expectations

    Report insufficient evidence rather than guess

    Which one
    Judgement
    Why
    The honest description of what you hold

    What strong practice looks like

    Professional practice
    • Write the reason beside the decision when you make it. A one-line note in your mark book is what makes the judgement explainable in November.
    • Test the decision against the overall expectations, not against the assignment list.
    • Where you are unsure, moderate with a colleague on the same grade before you finalise.

    What this looks like in practice

    A student who starts poorly and finishes strongly

    Instead of: Average everything and report a level 2.

    Report the level the most recent, most consistent evidence on those overall expectations shows, and note in your records why the early attempts carry less weight.

    Why it works: The grade is meant to represent achievement of the overall expectations, which the later evidence describes more accurately.

    A missed unit test with strong classwork

    Evaluate from the observations, conversations and products you do hold for those expectations, and arrange a second opportunity if the coverage is thin.

    Why it works: Judgement operates on the evidence you have; where the evidence is thin, the answer is to collect more rather than to estimate.

    Practical suggestions

    Practical classroom suggestion
    • Keep the outlier visible in your records rather than deleting it; explaining why you set it aside is stronger than hiding it.
    • Use the phrase 'the evidence shows' when you talk to families — it keeps the conversation on learning.
    • If two teachers with the same evidence would land in different places, that is a moderation conversation, not a judgement call.

    Common mistakes

    Treating professional judgement as permission to override policy.

    Instead: It is judgement exercised within policy, about what the evidence shows.

    Using it to reward effort.

    Instead: Effort belongs in learning skills and work habits; the grade stays with achievement of the expectations.

    Making the decision and recording nothing.

    Instead: Note the reason at the time. Unexplained judgement is indistinguishable from arbitrariness.

    The takeaway

    Professional judgement is the reasoned reading of the evidence against the overall expectations — defensible, explainable and recorded. If you cannot state the reason, it is a preference wearing the word.

    Ontario sources

    Every source we cite, with its verification date, is listed in the public source index.

    Was this answer helpful?

    Prepared by Ontario Curriculum AI.

    Last reviewed 2026-08-19 · next review 2027-02-19

    Ontario Curriculum AI supports professional work. Educators retain professional judgement for all assessment, evaluation and reporting decisions.