What Ontario Secondary Teachers Need to Know About Assessment and Evaluation in 2026–27
The Grades 9–12 rules have not changed as often as the conversation around them suggests. Here is what Growing Success actually requires, what is a board procedure, what is your professional judgement, and how to run a semester where the mark at the end is defensible.
- Published
- September 8, 2026
- Reading time
- 18 minutes
- Grades
- Grades 9 to 12
- Subjects
- All secondary subjects
Quick answer
What are the assessment and evaluation rules for Ontario secondary teachers?
In Ontario Grades 9–12, Growing Success (2010) sets the framework: a final grade is based 70 per cent on evidence gathered throughout the course and 30 per cent on a final evaluation. Grades reflect the most consistent level of achievement of the overall expectations, with special consideration for more recent evidence. Learning Skills and Work Habits are reported separately from the grade, and a student earns the credit with 50 per cent or more.
- 70 per cent term work, 30 per cent final evaluation — a course-long requirement, not a unit-by-unit one.
- The grade reflects the most consistent level of achievement, not a pure average.
- The six Learning Skills are reported separately and never folded into the mark.
- Assessment for and as learning is not counted in the grade.
- Zeros, late penalties and missed work are governed by board procedure inside Growing Success Chapter 8.
Late October, period four prep, a semestered Grade 10 course
There are thirty-one names in the gradebook and eleven of them have a blank where the first evaluation should be. Two students have handed in work three weeks late. One has an IEP with accommodations the teacher has been applying but has not written down anywhere. A department meeting last week produced three different answers to the same question about late work, and none of them came from a document anyone could name.
The end-of-semester mark has to be defensible to a student, a parent, an administrator and — occasionally — an appeal. Defensible does not mean complicated. It means every mark can be traced to evidence, and every rule you applied can be traced to something written down.
Key Takeaways
Everything below in under a minute
- The 70/30 split applies to the course as a whole. Nothing requires each unit or each category to follow it.
- A final grade is a professional judgement about the most consistent level of achievement, informed by more recent evidence — not the number a spreadsheet returns by default.
- The four achievement chart categories are how you organise evidence all semester, not four boxes to fill in during the last week.
- Learning Skills are reported separately, and are evaluated on evidence gathered over time rather than on compliance.
- Late and missed assignments are addressed with a range of strategies; a mark of zero is a last resort, taken with professional judgement and within board procedure.
- The strongest defence of a mark is a record: expectations assessed, evidence gathered, feedback given, accommodations applied.
How a Grades 9–12 final grade is actually built
Four layers sit between a course's overall expectations and the number on the report card. Every one of them is a place where evidence is gathered, and only the last two are evaluation.
Overall expectations
The course's overall expectations are what a grade represents. Specific expectations inform instruction and are assessed in service of them.
Assessment for and as learning
Diagnostic and formative evidence, descriptive feedback, self- and peer-assessment. Not counted in the grade.
Term evaluation — 70 per cent
Evidence of achievement gathered throughout the course across the four achievement chart categories, weighted by your professional judgement about consistency and recency.
Final evaluation — 30 per cent
An exam, a performance task, an essay, a portfolio defence, or a combination, administered towards the end of the course.
Learning Skills and Work Habits run alongside all four layers and are reported separately on the provincial report card.
Start with what has not changed
Growing Success (2010) remains the assessment, evaluation and reporting policy for Ontario schools, Grades 1 to 12. The seven fundamental principles, the achievement chart, the 70/30 requirement for Grades 9 to 12, the separate reporting of Learning Skills and Work Habits, and the direction to base grades on the most consistent level of achievement all still stand. That matters because most staffroom disagreements about assessment are not disagreements about policy. They are disagreements about department practice, gradebook software defaults or personal habit, held with the confidence of policy. When a colleague tells you something is 'the rule', the useful question is which document it is in.
Most assessment arguments in a secondary department are not about policy. They are about habits that have been repeated long enough to sound like policy.
The 70/30 split, read accurately
For Grades 9 to 12, seventy per cent of the final grade is based on evidence of achievement gathered throughout the course, and thirty per cent on a final evaluation administered towards the end. Two things follow that teachers often miss. First, the seventy per cent is not an average of everything a student ever submitted: it reflects the most consistent level of achievement, with special consideration for the more recent evidence. A student who begins a course at Level 2 and finishes consistently at Level 3 has demonstrated Level 3 achievement, and the grade should say so. Second, the final evaluation does not have to be a written examination. It can be an exam, a performance task, an essay, a culminating project, a portfolio, or a combination. What it must be is a valid evaluation of the course's overall expectations, administered towards the end of the course.
The achievement chart is a planning tool, not a reporting chore
Every Ontario curriculum document contains an achievement chart with four categories: Knowledge and Understanding, Thinking, Communication, and Application. They describe the kinds of achievement a course develops, and they are meant to shape assessment design from the first week. Used well, the categories protect students. A course evaluated almost entirely through Knowledge and Understanding tests produces a grade that says very little about whether a student can think, communicate or apply. Used late, they become a scramble in the final fortnight to find a Communication mark for everyone. Category weighting is a professional decision made in the context of the course and your department's agreements. What is not optional is that all four categories are represented in the evidence behind the grade.
Learning Skills and Work Habits stay out of the mark
The six Learning Skills and Work Habits — Responsibility, Organization, Independent Work, Collaboration, Initiative, and Self-Regulation — are evaluated and reported separately from the grade, using the letters E, G, S and N. This is the single most commonly broken rule in secondary assessment, and it is usually broken with good intentions: marks deducted for lateness, participation marks that are really attendance, bonus marks for effort. Each of those quietly turns the grade into a report on behaviour rather than on achievement of the curriculum expectations. The separate report is not a lesser report. For many students and families it is the more useful of the two, and it is the part of the report card that most often changes a conversation.
Late and missed assignments
Growing Success devotes a full chapter to this, and its position is more nuanced than either side of the usual staffroom argument. Teachers use a range of strategies before a mark is affected: clear timelines, chunked tasks with interim check-ins, conversations with the student, contact home, planning support, alternative arrangements, and support from other school staff. When work is genuinely never submitted, teachers exercise professional judgement, within their board's procedures, about how the missing evidence is treated. A mark of zero is a last resort rather than an automatic consequence, because a zero is a statement that the student has demonstrated no achievement — which is rarely what the rest of the evidence shows. Boards may set specific late-work procedures. Yours is the document that answers the practical question of what a deduction may look like in your school.
Students with an IEP, and multilingual learners
Accommodations change how a student demonstrates learning; they do not change the expectations, and work completed with accommodations is evaluated against the same curriculum expectations as everyone else's. Nothing on the report card or in the grade signals that accommodations were used. Modified expectations are different: they change what is being assessed, are documented in the IEP, and are reflected in reporting accordingly. Alternative programming is different again. For multilingual learners, accommodations and — where appropriate — modified expectations follow the student's stage of English language proficiency and are documented, so that a language barrier is not evaluated as an achievement gap.
Generative AI and academic honesty
Generative AI has changed how much unsupervised written work can tell you about a student's learning. Policy has not changed the underlying requirement: evaluation must be based on evidence of the student's own achievement. The practical response in most secondary classrooms has been to shift some evaluation into conditions you can observe — in-class writing, oral defences of submitted work, process evidence, drafts, conferences — rather than to police finished products. That is a design change, not a policy one, and it is offered here as an interpretation of good practice rather than as a Ministry requirement. Academic honesty procedures are set by your board and are the correct reference point when a specific incident occurs.
Reporting and credits
Grades 9 to 12 achievement is reported on the Provincial Report Card, Grades 9–12, with a percentage mark, Learning Skills ratings and comments. A student earns the credit for a course with a final grade of 50 per cent or more. Comments describe significant strengths and next steps for improvement in language a student and family can act on. A comment that could apply to any student in the class is a comment that took time to write and gives nobody anything to do.
Ontario classroom examples
The same idea, written the way it actually sounds in each division.
A student's first two unit tests sit at Level 1, then everything from November onward is consistently Level 3.
The final grade reflects Level 3. The teacher's note in the gradebook reads: 'Most consistent achievement of the overall expectations is Level 3; recent evidence (units 3–5, plus the culminating task) is consistently at that level. Early evidence retained for the record, not weighted equally.'
Growing Success (2010), Chapter 3 — most consistent level of achievement
An essay arrives eleven days late, after two check-ins and a call home.
The essay is evaluated on its achievement of the expectations. The lateness is documented and reported through Responsibility and Organization. The teacher records: 'Interim check-ins Oct 14 and Oct 21; contact home Oct 22; submitted Nov 2. Achievement Level 3; Responsibility S.'
Growing Success (2010), Chapter 8 — late and missed assignments
A student with an IEP uses extended time and speech-to-text for the unit evaluation.
The work is marked against the same expectations and the same criteria as the rest of the class. Nothing is noted on the report card about accommodations. In the teacher's own record: 'Extended time + speech-to-text provided as per IEP, Nov 6.'
Growing Success (2010), Chapter 6 — students with special education needs
The department wants to replace the traditional written exam as the final evaluation.
A culminating research task with an oral defence, administered in the final two weeks, is a valid final evaluation provided it evaluates the course's overall expectations. It counts for the same 30 per cent an exam would.
Growing Success (2010), Chapter 3 — the final evaluation in Grades 9–12
A de-streamed class contains a very wide range of prior achievement in the same room.
The evaluation stays common; the supports differ. Same task, same criteria, with scaffolds — a planning frame, a worked example, a vocabulary bank — available to anyone. Differentiated support with a common evaluation is a practical interpretation, not a policy requirement.
Ontario Curriculum, Grade 9 Science (2022)
A student's ideas are strong and the written French is not yet secure.
Thinking and Application are evaluated on the quality of the ideas and their use; Communication is evaluated on the language. Separating them by category is what keeps one weakness from suppressing four.
Achievement chart categories, Ontario Curriculum
See it in an Ontario classroom
The same idea at your grade level — teacher language, anchor chart, lesson flow and the evidence it leaves behind.
November in Ontario schools: Open Report Card Comments.
What the policy requires, and what your department decided
Useful in a department meeting when the same question produces four answers.
Grade composition
Ministry requirement: 70 per cent term, 30 per cent final evaluation across the course
Board procedure or department practice: Which task serves as the final evaluation
Determining the grade
Ministry requirement: Most consistent level of achievement, with special consideration for recent evidence
Board procedure or department practice: The gradebook software and its default calculation
Categories
Ministry requirement: All four achievement chart categories represented
Board procedure or department practice: The specific category weightings for the course
Learning Skills
Ministry requirement: Six skills, reported separately using E, G, S, N
Board procedure or department practice: The tracking tool used to gather the evidence
Late work
Ministry requirement: A range of strategies; zero as a last resort, using professional judgement
Board procedure or department practice: The specific late-work procedure in your board
Reassessment
Ministry requirement: Not prescribed in detail
Board procedure or department practice: Almost always a department or board decision
Credit
Ministry requirement: 50 per cent or more earns the credit
Board procedure or department practice: Credit rescue and recovery structures in your school
When something sits in the right-hand column, it can be discussed and changed. When it sits in the left, it cannot — and knowing the difference saves entire meetings.
How to implement this tomorrow
A semester-length rhythm. Nothing here needs a new tool; it needs the decisions made early enough that January is a summary rather than a reconstruction.
Preparation
- Read your board's assessment procedure once, at the start of the semester, and note where it is more specific than Growing Success
- Map every planned evaluation to an achievement chart category and to the overall expectations it evaluates
- Decide the final evaluation in week one, not week fifteen
- Set up a Learning Skills record you will realistically maintain — a column per skill and a date is enough
Materials
- The curriculum document for the course, with the achievement chart
- Growing Success (2010), Chapters 3, 6 and 8
- Your board's assessment and academic honesty procedures
- A gradebook you can annotate, not only calculate in
Time required
About two hours of set-up, then ten minutes a week
Weeks 1–2 — build the evidence plan
90 minutesTeacher actions
- Write the course's overall expectations at the top of the plan and group evaluations under them
- Confirm all four achievement chart categories appear more than once
- Share the assessment plan with students in plain language
Student actions
- Read the plan and ask what the final evaluation will be
Weeks 3–8 — gather evidence and give feedback
10 minutes a weekTeacher actions
- Keep assessment for learning out of the grade and say so out loud when you return it
- Record one dated Learning Skills observation per student every two weeks
- Note accommodations as you provide them
Student actions
- Act on descriptive feedback before the evaluation that follows it
Weeks 9–14 — check the pattern, not the average
One prep periodTeacher actions
- Look for students whose recent evidence differs from their calculated mark and decide, deliberately, which one the grade should reflect
- Follow up missing evidence with strategies before it becomes a gap
- Draft Learning Skills ratings from your dated notes
Weeks 15–18 — final evaluation and reporting
Two prep periods plus markingTeacher actions
- Administer the final evaluation as a valid evaluation of the overall expectations
- Determine each grade as a professional judgement, annotate anything you adjusted, and write comments that name a strength and a next step
Reflection
- Which students' grades did I adjust away from the calculated figure, and can I explain each one?
- Did any behaviour end up inside a mark this semester?
- Which achievement chart category was thinnest in my evidence, and what will I redesign next semester?
- Whose Learning Skills rating did I write from memory rather than from notes?
Challenges and solutions
- A student disputes a grade at the end of the semester
- Show the evidence, the pattern and the professional judgement in writing. A grade you can trace is a grade you can explain; the conversation becomes about learning rather than about arithmetic.
- Your department's practice conflicts with Growing Success
- Name the document rather than the disagreement. 'Chapter 8 asks for a range of strategies before a mark is affected' moves a meeting further than a position does.
- Half the class has missing work in November
- Treat it as an instructional problem first: chunk the task, add interim deadlines, and use class time for a check-in. Missing work at that scale is usually a design signal, not thirty individual choices.
- You inherit a course mid-semester
- Audit the evidence against the four categories and the overall expectations before adding anything new. You are accountable for the grade you submit, not the one you were handed.
Ontario terms in this article
Definitions, in Ministry language
- Differentiated Instruction
- Differentiated instruction adjusts content, process, product or learning environment in response to student readiness, interest and learning preference, while keeping the same curriculum expectations for the class. Differentiated Instruction resources
- Learning Skills and Work Habits
- Ontario report cards evaluate six learning skills and work habits — responsibility, organization, independent work, collaboration, initiative and self-regulation — separately from subject achievement, using E, G, S and N. Learning Skills and Work Habits resources
- Assessment of Learning
- Assessment of learning is the evaluation used to determine a student's level of achievement at a given point, reported as a level or percentage grade on the Ontario report card. Assessment of Learning resources
- Ontario Ministry of Education
- The Ontario Ministry of Education sets curriculum policy, assessment policy and reporting requirements for publicly funded schools in Ontario. Ontario Ministry of Education resources
- Growing Success (2010)
- Growing Success (2010) is Ontario's policy document for assessment, evaluation and reporting in Grades 1 to 12. It defines the Achievement Chart, the learning skills and work habits, and the role of professional judgement in determining a report card grade. Growing Success (2010) resources
- Professional Judgement
- Professional judgement is the informed decision-making Ontario teachers use to determine a grade from the whole body of evidence, weighting the most recent and most consistent work rather than averaging every mark. Professional Judgement resources
Frequently Asked Questions
0% read · about 18 min left
Keep going
Apply this to my classroom™
Apply "What Ontario Secondary Teachers Need to Know About Assessment and Evaluation in 2026–27" this week
Choose one idea from this article and put it into a lesson you are already teaching.
- Time
- About 24 minutes
- Steps
- 5
- You will finish with
- One concrete piece of classroom work, finished rather than planned.
Opens a guided workshop. Your progress and reflections stay private on this device.
Adapt This for My Classroom™
Rewrite this article for the class you actually teach
Journal will take what you have just read and turn it into a plan sized for your grades, your subjects and the students in your room — with the differentiation moves already worked out.
Tell Journal about your classroom once and every article can adapt to it.
Your profile stays on your device. Only the general shape of your class is sent to generate the plan — never a student name. Everything here is a draft for your professional judgment.
Keep going with Ontario Curriculum AI
Everything below is part of the same Ontario knowledge base — guides, tools and templates that build on this article.
Cornerstone guides
- The Complete Ontario Curriculum GuideHow to read, unpack and sequence Ontario expectations from Kindergarten to Grade 12 — strands, codes, revised documents and coverage.
- The Complete Growing Success GuideOntario's assessment, evaluation and reporting policy in full — levels, qualifiers, learning skills and the rules that govern a mark.
Do it with a tool
Resources and support
- Free Ontario teacher resources and templatesComment banks, rubrics, planning organizers and parent communication templates.
- Help Centre guides for every generatorStep-by-step instructions for each tool, export format and account setting.
- How Ontario Curriculum AI protects student privacyCanadian hosting, PIPEDA alignment and why no identifiable student data is stored.
- Reviewed by Ontario educators
- Updated on a 90-day review cycle
- Built in Ontario
- Growing Success aligned
- Privacy-first — no student data stored
- Evidence-informed
Reviewed each August, and whenever Ministry assessment policy changes
Ontario Curriculum AI Newsletter
Practical Ontario assessment guidance, every week
- Exclusive editable templates
- New AI tools as they ship
- Ontario teacher guides
- Free downloads
- Seasonal resources for each reporting period
Get Ontario Reporting & Planning Updates
New tools, reporting-season guides, and policy insights for Ontario educators.
No spam. Ontario-focused updates only. Unsubscribe anytime.
Ready to get these hours back?
Everything in this article can be drafted for your grade, subject and class in a single sitting. You still apply your professional judgment — the tool just removes the blank page.
- Built for Ontario, not adapted to it
- Growing Success aligned language
- No student data required
- Canadian hosting, PIPEDA aligned
- Free plan available
Teachers also read
- The Complete Guide to Ontario Learning SkillsThe separate report that carries the behaviour evidence.
- Assessment for Learning in OntarioThe evidence that never enters the grade.
- Learning Goals and Success CriteriaWhere a defensible evaluation starts.
- Ontario Report Card CommentsWriting the strength and the next step.
- The First Day of SchoolWhere the semester's first observations come from.
Recommended learning journey
You just read about You just worked through assessment and evaluation in Grades 9–12.. Here is what comes next.
Editorial information
- Last updated
- September 8, 2026
- Reading time
- 18 minutes
- Difficulty
- practical
- Ontario grade levels
- Grades 9 to 12
- Applicable subjects
- All secondary subjects
- Applicable AI tools
- Rubric BuilderAssessment Generator
- Evidence level
- Ontario Ministry policy (Growing Success)
- Editorial confidence
- High — verified against current Ministry documents
Every draft produced by Ontario Curriculum AI is a starting point. Ontario educators remain responsible for professional judgment, board policy and the accuracy of anything sent home.