Skip to content

    Learning Goals vs Success Criteria: The Complete Ontario Teacher Guide

    What each one is, how they differ, where they come from in the Ontario curriculum, and exactly how to write both for any lesson — with 25 ready-to-use learning goals and 75 student-friendly success criteria.

    Published
    August 13, 2026
    Reading time
    28 minutes
    Grades
    Kindergarten to Grade 8 (adaptable for secondary)
    Subjects
    All subjects
    Ontario curriculum documents, all grades and subjects; The Kindergarten Program (2016)Growing Success (2010) — learning goals, success criteria, assessment for and as learning, descriptive feedback, the Achievement Chart

    Written by Ontario Curriculum AI Editorial Team · Ontario educators and curriculum writers

    Editorially reviewed by Ontario Curriculum AI Review Panel · August 2026

    August 2026Editorially reviewedOntario terminology verifiedGrowing Success verifiedAI reviewed

    Quick answer

    What is the difference between a learning goal and success criteria in Ontario?

    A learning goal answers 'What are we learning today?' — it states, in student-friendly language, the knowledge or skill drawn from an Ontario curriculum expectation. Success criteria answer 'How will we know we have learned it?' — they describe the specific, observable evidence students will produce. One goal per lesson; several criteria beneath it.

    • Learning goals describe the destination; success criteria describe the evidence
    • Both come from Ontario curriculum expectations, rewritten in student language
    • Growing Success (2010) identifies both as essential to assessment for learning
    • Success criteria are most powerful when co-constructed with students
    • Together they make feedback, self-assessment and evaluation far more precise

    Tuesday, 9:05 a.m., two Grade 4 classrooms across the hall from each other

    Both teachers have planned well. Both have chosen the same overall expectation from the Ontario mathematics curriculum. Both have manipulatives out, both have a hands-on task ready, and both have a consolidation planned for the last ten minutes. In the first room, the teacher writes four words on the board: We are learning about fractions. In the second room, the teacher writes a learning goal — we are learning how fractions represent equal parts of a whole — and underneath it three lines the class wrote together yesterday: I can show equal parts. I can explain why the parts are equal. I can represent the same fraction in more than one way. Forty minutes later, the lessons look almost identical from the doorway. But when a student in the first room is asked what she is working on, she says 'the fraction sheet'. In the second room, the same question gets a different answer: 'I can already show equal parts, so I am working on the second one — explaining why.'

    Both teachers taught fractions. Only one made the learning visible. That difference — between a topic and a goal, between an activity and evidence — is the difference between students completing your lesson and students knowing what they are learning and how close they are to getting there.

    Key Takeaways

    Everything below in under a minute

    • A learning goal is the destination. Success criteria are the evidence that you have arrived. Confusing the two is the single most common planning error in Ontario classrooms.
    • Both are derived from curriculum expectations — but a curriculum expectation is written for teachers, and a learning goal is written for students. The translation is the work.
    • One clear learning goal per lesson is almost always enough. Three to five success criteria beneath it is the sweet spot.
    • Write learning goals with 'We are learning to…' and success criteria with 'I can…'. The pronouns matter: the goal is shared, the evidence is personal.
    • Success criteria describe what a student does, not what a student hands in. 'I can explain my thinking using a model' beats 'complete page 42'.
    • Co-construct criteria wherever possible. Students who help build the criteria understand them, use them, and hold themselves to them.
    • Post them, refer to them mid-lesson, and return to them in consolidation. A learning goal shown once at 9:05 and never mentioned again is decoration.

    The Ontario planning sequence: expectation to next steps

    Learning goals and success criteria are not standalone templates. They are two links in a chain that runs from the curriculum document to the feedback a student receives on Friday. When any link is missing, the ones after it weaken.

    1

    Ontario curriculum expectation

    The overall and specific expectations in the ministry document. Written for teachers, in policy language, and covering more than one lesson's worth of learning.

    2

    Learning goal

    One expectation, unbundled and rewritten for students. 'We are learning to…' — the destination for this lesson or short sequence of lessons.

    3

    Success criteria

    The observable evidence that the goal has been met. Three to five 'I can…' statements, ideally co-constructed with the class using an exemplar.

    4

    Lesson activities

    Tasks chosen because they generate the evidence named in the criteria — not activities chosen first and justified afterwards.

    5

    Assessment

    Observations, conversations and products gathered against the criteria. The same criteria become the descriptors in the rubric for the eventual evaluation.

    6

    Descriptive feedback

    Feedback written in the language of the criteria: what the student did well against a named criterion, and which criterion to work on next.

    7

    Next steps

    The student's next goal, your next mini-lesson, tomorrow's grouping — and, in December and June, the evidence base for the report card comment.

    Steps two and three are the ones teachers most often skip when time is short. They are also the two that make every step after them faster.

    Section 1 — What are learning goals?

    A learning goal is a brief statement, written in language your students can read and understand, that describes what they will know or be able to do by the end of a lesson or short sequence of lessons. In Ontario, the terminology comes directly from Growing Success (2010), which describes learning goals as statements based on the curriculum expectations that describe, in language students can readily understand, what they should know and be able to do by the end of a period of instruction. You will also see the phrase learning intention in professional learning and in board documents; in an Ontario context the two mean the same thing, and ministry materials favour learning goal. The essential characteristic is not the sentence stem. It is the shift in audience. A curriculum expectation is written for a teacher planning a year. A learning goal is written for a nine-year-old planning the next forty minutes.

    A learning goal is not a topic, an activity, or an expectation

    Three impostors show up constantly on Ontario whiteboards. The first is the topic: 'Fractions.' 'The water cycle.' 'Persuasive writing.' A topic tells students what the lesson is about but nothing about what they are meant to learn from it. The second is the activity: 'We are making a poster about the water cycle.' This describes the task, not the learning, and it teaches students that finishing is the goal. The third — the most understandable mistake, and the most common in the first years of teaching — is the copied curriculum expectation: 'Demonstrate an understanding of the processes involved in the water cycle, including evaporation, condensation, precipitation and collection.' It is accurate, it is aligned, and it is unreadable to the students it was posted for. A learning goal sits between them: 'We are learning how water moves between the ground, the air and the clouds, and why it keeps repeating.'

    The same learning, in three registers

    Curriculum expectation (Grade 4 Language, reading): identify the main idea and several interconnected supporting details in a variety of texts. Topic version: 'Main idea.' Activity version: 'We are doing the main idea worksheet.' Learning goal version: 'We are learning to find the big idea in a text and the details that support it.' Only the last one tells a student both what they are working on and what they should be able to do when the lesson ends.

    Learning goals across the Ontario subjects

    Language: We are learning to use evidence from the text to support our thinking. Mathematics: We are learning to compare fractions with different denominators. Science and Technology: We are learning how forces make objects start, stop and change direction. Social Studies: We are learning to look at an event from more than one perspective. The Arts: We are learning how an artist uses contrast to draw the viewer's eye. Health and Physical Education: We are learning to name strategies that help us calm our bodies. French: Nous apprenons à poser des questions simples pour obtenir de l'information. Kindergarten: We are learning that our thinking can change when we notice something new.

    Section 2 — What are success criteria?

    Success criteria describe, in specific and observable terms, what a student will say, do, make or write to demonstrate that the learning goal has been met. If the learning goal is the destination, the criteria are the landmarks that tell you and the student that you have arrived. Growing Success describes them as the standards or specific descriptions of successful attainment, developed by teachers on the basis of the curriculum expectations and the Achievement Chart, and shared with students. In practice, Ontario classrooms almost always write them as 'I can…' statements, because the first person makes the evidence personal and usable: a student can point at a criterion and say, honestly, whether they can do it yet.

    Observable is the whole game

    The test of a success criterion is simple: could two different teachers, watching the same student, agree on whether the criterion has been met? 'I can understand fractions' fails immediately — understanding is invisible. 'I can show one half in three different ways' passes, because you can see it happen. Words like understand, know, appreciate, be aware of and be familiar with belong in a learning goal, where the destination is allowed to be abstract. They do not belong in criteria, where the whole point is visible evidence. Replace them with verbs a student can be watched doing: show, explain, compare, justify, label, sort, model, revise, cite, represent, choose, defend.

    One goal, five criteria — Grade 5 persuasive writing

    Learning goal: We are learning to write an opinion piece that convinces a reader. Success criteria, co-constructed after examining two exemplars: I can state my opinion clearly in the first paragraph. I can give three reasons for my opinion. I can support each reason with an example or a fact. I can use linking words to connect my ideas. I can end by restating my opinion in a new way. Five criteria, all visible in the writing, all usable by a student in the middle of a draft.

    Section 3 — The difference, stated plainly

    The learning goal is singular, conceptual and shared: it names the destination for the whole class. The success criteria are plural, concrete and personal: they name the evidence each student will produce. The goal is written with 'we' because the class is travelling together. The criteria are written with 'I' because the evidence belongs to each student individually. A goal answers what and why. Criteria answer how you will know. A goal rarely changes during a lesson; criteria are often added to as the class discovers what quality actually looks like. And crucially, a goal on its own leaves students guessing at your standard, while criteria on their own leave students completing a checklist with no idea what it adds up to. Neither works well alone. Together they are one of the most reliably effective instructional practices available to an Ontario teacher.

    Section 4 — Where do curriculum expectations fit?

    Every learning goal in an Ontario classroom traces back to an expectation in a ministry curriculum document. Overall expectations describe the broad knowledge and skills students are expected to demonstrate by the end of the grade; specific expectations describe the particular knowledge and skills that contribute to them. Neither is a learning goal, because neither is written for students, and most specific expectations bundle several lessons' worth of learning. The planning move is called unbundling: take one specific expectation, identify the distinct pieces of learning inside it, and turn each piece into its own learning goal for its own lesson.

    Unbundling one expectation into three lessons

    Take a Grade 6 measurement expectation that asks students to determine and apply the relationships between the area of a parallelogram and the area of a triangle. Inside it there are at least three distinct learnings. Lesson one goal: We are learning how the area of a parallelogram relates to the area of a rectangle. Lesson two goal: We are learning how the area of a triangle relates to the area of a parallelogram. Lesson three goal: We are learning to choose and justify a strategy for finding the area of a composite shape. One expectation, three goals, three sets of criteria, one coherent week. The expectation was never a lesson; it was a unit.

    Section 5 — Writing strong learning goals

    Start with the verb in the curriculum expectation, because it tells you the cognitive demand: identify is not analyse, and describe is not justify. Then ask what a student would have to understand, not merely do, in order to meet it. Write the destination in one sentence a student could read aloud without stumbling. Then apply four tests. Is it about learning rather than an activity? Is it in student language? Is it one thing rather than three? Could you name the evidence that would convince you it had been met? If the fourth test fails, the goal is still too vague — and vague goals produce vague criteria, vague feedback, and vague report card comments six months later.

    Grade-by-grade examples across the Ontario subjects

    Grade 1 Language: We are learning to use the pictures and the letters to figure out a word we do not know. Grade 2 Mathematics: We are learning to use place value to explain what a number is worth. Grade 3 Science: We are learning why some structures are stronger than others. Grade 4 Social Studies: We are learning how the environment shapes the way people live. Grade 5 Health: We are learning to recognise the signs of stress in our own bodies. Grade 6 The Arts: We are learning how an artist uses colour to create a mood. Grade 7 Language: We are learning to detect bias in a media text. Grade 8 Mathematics: We are learning to justify whether a relationship is linear. Kindergarten: We are learning that we can test our ideas to find out if they work. French Immersion: Nous apprenons à utiliser des mots de transition pour relier nos idées.

    Section 6 — Writing success criteria students actually understand

    Read your criteria aloud in the voice of the youngest reader in your room. If any word would stop them, replace it. 'I can utilise appropriate text features to locate information' becomes 'I can use headings and bold words to find what I need'. Keep each criterion to a single idea; a criterion joined by 'and' is usually two criteria wearing one coat. Anchor each one to something visible. And wherever it is possible, build them with the class from exemplars rather than handing them down — the twelve minutes co-construction costs is repaid every time a student uses the chart instead of raising a hand to ask whether they are finished.

    Vague to usable — four rewrites

    'I can understand the story' becomes 'I can retell what happened in order, using the characters' names'. 'I can do good work' becomes 'I can check my work against the criteria and fix one thing before I hand it in'. 'I can participate' becomes 'I can add an idea that builds on what someone else said'. 'I can solve the problem' becomes 'I can show my strategy with a model, numbers or words so someone else could follow it'. In every case the change is the same: from an invisible state to a visible action.

    Section 7 — Six complete classroom examples

    The examples that follow move from expectation to learning goal to criteria to activity to assessment opportunity to a sample piece of descriptive feedback. Read one in full — the value is in seeing the whole chain hold together, because that coherence is what makes the practice work rather than any individual sentence within it.

    Grade 1 Reading

    Expectation: use a variety of reading comprehension strategies to understand texts. Learning goal: We are learning to use what we already know to help us understand a story. Criteria: I can tell about something in my own life that is like the story. I can say what I think will happen next. I can find a picture or word that helped me know. Activity: interactive read-aloud with turn-and-talk stops. Assessment opportunity: observation notes during turn-and-talk, three students per session. Feedback: 'You made a really clear connection to your own family. Next time, tell me which part of the story made you think of it.'

    Grade 3 Mathematics

    Expectation: represent and compare fractions of a whole. Learning goal: We are learning how fractions show equal parts of a whole. Criteria: I can divide a shape into equal parts. I can name the fraction using the number of parts. I can show the same fraction in two different ways. I can explain why the parts have to be equal. Activity: paper folding, then an open sort of 'is this one quarter?' cards. Assessment opportunity: the sort itself, plus a two-minute conversation with four students. Feedback: 'Your folding shows equal parts every time. Your next step is criterion four — explaining why unequal parts cannot be quarters.'

    Grade 5 Science and Technology

    Expectation: investigate the properties of and interactions among forces acting on structures. Learning goal: We are learning how forces can make a structure fail. Criteria: I can name the force acting on my structure. I can predict where it will fail and say why. I can change one thing and test again. I can explain what my change did. Activity: bridge-building with a load test. Assessment opportunity: observation of the second build, where the change is deliberate. Feedback: 'You named compression accurately and your prediction matched what happened. Next: change only one variable so you know what caused the improvement.'

    Grade 6 Social Studies

    Expectation: analyse different perspectives on an issue of political or social significance. Learning goal: We are learning that people can look at the same event in very different ways, depending on who they are. Criteria: I can describe the event using facts. I can explain two different perspectives on it. I can say what might cause each perspective. I can use evidence to support what I say. Activity: perspective placemat with four source cards. Assessment opportunity: the placemat as a product, plus small-group conversation. Feedback: 'Both perspectives are clearly described. Push on criterion three — what is it about each group's situation that leads them to see it that way?'

    Grade 8 Language

    Expectation: identify the point of view presented in texts and suggest other possible perspectives. Learning goal: We are learning to notice whose voice is missing from a text. Criteria: I can identify the point of view in the text. I can name at least one perspective that is not represented. I can explain how including it would change the message. I can support my thinking with specific evidence from the text. Activity: paired analysis of two news reports on the same event. Assessment opportunity: written response, assessed against the same four criteria that appear in the rubric. Feedback: 'Your identification of the missing voice is sharp. Strengthen criterion four — quote the line that led you there.'

    Kindergarten inquiry

    Frame: Problem Solving and Innovating. Learning goal: We are learning that we can test our ideas to find out if they work. Criteria, spoken and drawn rather than written: I can say my idea out loud. I can try my idea. I can tell what happened. I can try a new way if it did not work. Activity: ramps and rolling objects at the block centre. Assessment opportunity: pedagogical documentation — a photograph with the child's own words recorded beneath it. Feedback: 'You said the car would go faster on the tall ramp, and you tried it. What could we change to make it go even further?'

    Section 8 — Using learning goals throughout the lesson

    The most common failure of this practice is not writing bad goals. It is writing good ones and then never mentioning them again. In an Ontario three-part lesson the goal has a job in every part. At the start, it frames the minds-on: name it, read it together, and ask what students think it will look like when they can do it. During the working part, it is a question rather than a poster: which criterion are you working on right now? At consolidation, it is the organising structure — return to the goal, ask what evidence the class produced, and add a criterion if the work revealed something the original list missed. And in the last two minutes, it becomes the exit ticket: which criterion can you already do, and which one are you still working on?

    Section 9 — Connecting success criteria to assessment

    Growing Success organises classroom assessment into three purposes, and success criteria serve all three. In assessment for learning, criteria tell you what to look for as you observe, converse and collect products, and they tell students what to aim at before the work begins. In assessment as learning, criteria are the instrument students use to self-assess, set goals and monitor their own progress — the practice is essentially impossible without them. In assessment of learning, criteria become the substance of the rubric: the four Achievement Chart categories describe the kind of learning being evaluated, and your criteria describe what that learning looks like in this task at this grade. When the rubric a student receives uses the same wording as the chart on the wall, evaluation stops feeling like a verdict from nowhere.

    From criteria to rubric without rewriting anything

    Criterion: 'I can support each reason with an example or a fact.' Level 3 descriptor: supports each reason with a relevant example or fact. Level 4: supports each reason with well-chosen evidence that strengthens the argument. Level 2: supports some reasons with examples, with limited relevance. Level 1: reasons are stated with little or no supporting evidence. The criterion did the work; the levels only describe degree. This is also precisely how the rubric builder and assessment generator construct levels — from the criteria you already wrote, in the Achievement Chart categories, in Ontario language.

    Section 10 — Differentiation: same goal, different criteria

    The principle is simple and it protects both equity and expectations: differentiate the criteria, not the goal. Everyone in the room is learning to write an opinion piece that convinces a reader. What differs is the evidence a particular student produces on the way there. A student with an IEP may meet the same goal through an oral recording rather than a written draft, with criteria adjusted for the accommodations in their plan. A multilingual learner in the early stages of English may demonstrate the same reasoning with sentence frames, first-language notes or a visual organiser. A student ready for more may take on an extended criterion — anticipating and answering a counterargument. Lowering the goal for a group is streaming in miniature. Adjusting the evidence, the scaffolds and the mode is what universal design for learning actually asks for.

    One goal, three sets of evidence

    Goal: We are learning to compare two numbers and explain which is greater. Core criteria: I can use place value language to explain which number is greater. Scaffolded: I can use base ten blocks to build both numbers, point to the one that is greater, and say why. Extended: I can explain a strategy that would work for any two numbers, including decimals, and test it. Three sets of criteria, one destination, and no student learning something categorically different from the child beside them.

    Section 12 — Helping students use goals independently

    The end state of this practice is not a well-decorated wall. It is a student who can say what they are learning, judge their own work against known criteria, name their next step, and ask for the help they actually need. That capacity is built deliberately. Start with self-assessment against a single criterion rather than the whole list. Teach peer feedback with a sentence frame that names a criterion: 'You met criterion two because…; for criterion three, you could try…'. Ask students to set one goal drawn from a criterion they have not yet met, and revisit it in two weeks so goal setting means something. Use learning conversations — 'show me the part you are proudest of, and tell me which criterion it meets' — instead of asking whether they are finished.

    Ontario classroom examples

    The same idea, written the way it actually sounds in each division.

    PrimaryGrade 1Language — Reading

    An interactive read-aloud with three turn-and-talk stops. The goal is read together at the start and the criteria are icons as well as words, so pre-readers can use them.

    Learning goal: We are learning to use what we already know to help us understand a story. I can tell about something in my life that is like the story. I can say what I think will happen next. I can point to the part that helped me know.

    Use a variety of reading comprehension strategies before, during and after reading to understand texts.

    JuniorGrade 3Mathematics — Number

    Paper folding followed by an open card sort: 'Is this one quarter?' Students place cards and must justify each placement to a partner using the criteria.

    Learning goal: We are learning how fractions show equal parts of a whole. I can divide a shape into equal parts. I can name the fraction. I can show the same fraction in two ways. I can explain why the parts have to be equal.

    Represent and compare fractions of a whole using appropriate tools and models.

    JuniorGrade 5Science and Technology — Structures

    A bridge build with a load test, then a second build in which students may change exactly one variable and must predict the effect first.

    Learning goal: We are learning how forces can make a structure fail. I can name the force acting on my structure. I can predict where it will fail and say why. I can change one thing and test again. I can explain what my change did.

    Investigate the properties of and interactions among forces acting on structures and mechanisms.

    IntermediateGrade 8Language — Media and Critical Literacy

    Paired analysis of two news reports covering the same event, with the same four criteria appearing on the wall chart and in the rubric attached to the written response.

    Learning goal: We are learning to notice whose voice is missing from a text. I can identify the point of view. I can name a perspective that is not represented. I can explain how including it would change the message. I can support my thinking with evidence from the text.

    Identify the point of view presented in texts and suggest other possible perspectives.

    French ImmersionGrade 4Français — Communication orale

    Une entrevue en dyades. Les critères sont affichés en français et co-construits à partir de deux modèles enregistrés que la classe écoute ensemble.

    Objectif d'apprentissage : Nous apprenons à poser des questions pour mieux comprendre. Je peux poser une question complète. Je peux écouter la réponse sans interrompre. Je peux poser une deuxième question liée à la réponse.

    Poser des questions pour obtenir de l'information et clarifier sa compréhension.

    Special EducationGrade 6Language — Writing (student with an IEP)

    The class learning goal is unchanged. The criteria are adjusted for the accommodations in the student's plan — speech-to-text for drafting, a graphic organiser, and an oral rehearsal before writing.

    Learning goal: We are learning to write an opinion piece that convinces a reader. I can say my opinion out loud and record it. I can give two reasons using my organiser. I can add one example to each reason with my partner's help.

    Write longer and more complex texts for a range of purposes and audiences.

    See it in an Ontario classroom

    The same idea at your grade level — teacher language, anchor chart, lesson flow and the evidence it leaves behind.

    November in Ontario schools: Open Report Card Comments.

    Learning goals and success criteria, side by side

    The clearest way to hold the distinction is to compare them on the dimensions that matter in planning. Read down either column and you have a definition; read across a row and you have the relationship.

    The question it answers

    Learning goal: What are we learning today?

    Success criteria: How will we know we have learned it?

    What it names

    Learning goal: The learning destination

    Success criteria: The evidence of learning

    Level of detail

    Learning goal: General and conceptual

    Success criteria: Specific and observable

    How many

    Learning goal: One per lesson (occasionally one across two or three lessons)

    Success criteria: Three to five per goal

    Focus

    Learning goal: Understanding and skill

    Success criteria: Demonstration and evidence

    Sentence stem

    Learning goal: We are learning to / that / how / why…

    Success criteria: I can…

    Pronoun and ownership

    Learning goal: 'We' — shared by the class

    Success criteria: 'I' — personal to each student

    Who writes it

    Learning goal: The teacher, from the curriculum expectation

    Success criteria: Ideally co-constructed with students from exemplars

    Where it comes from

    Learning goal: An unbundled Ontario curriculum expectation

    Success criteria: The expectation plus the Achievement Chart and exemplars of quality

    When it changes

    Learning goal: Rarely within a lesson

    Success criteria: Often added to as the class discovers what quality looks like

    Role in assessment

    Learning goal: Defines what is being assessed

    Success criteria: Defines what counts as evidence, and becomes the rubric descriptors

    Role in feedback

    Learning goal: Frames the conversation

    Success criteria: Provides the specific language of the next step

    Role in differentiation

    Learning goal: Stays the same for all students

    Success criteria: Scaffolded, extended or offered in a different mode

    If it is missing

    Learning goal: Students complete activities without knowing why

    Success criteria: Students guess at your standard and ask 'is this good?'

    One useful shortcut: if the statement could be true of a whole unit, it is probably a goal. If it describes something you could watch a student do in the next twenty minutes, it is a criterion.

    How to implement this tomorrow

    A realistic first two weeks for a teacher introducing learning goals and success criteria properly, rather than posting them and hoping. It assumes an ordinary Ontario elementary timetable and no additional planning time.

    Preparation

    • Choose one subject to start with — the one you teach most often, so the practice repeats daily
    • Pull the specific expectations for the unit you are about to teach and unbundle them into single-lesson learning goals
    • Collect two anonymous work samples for the first co-construction: one strong, one developing
    • Decide where the goal and criteria will live — a dedicated anchor chart space students can see from every seat
    • Write your first three learning goals in advance and read them aloud to check the language

    Materials

    • Chart paper or a dedicated whiteboard space, reserved permanently
    • Two anonymous exemplars per co-construction
    • Sticky notes for exit tickets against criteria
    • A criteria-referenced conference note template on a clipboard
    • Student-facing copies of the criteria: a half sheet, a desk card or a slide

    Time required

    About ten extra minutes of planning per lesson in week one, dropping to almost none by week three

    1. Days 1–3 — Make the goal visible and spoken

      Three minutes per lesson

      Teacher actions

      • Post one learning goal per lesson and read it aloud with the class
      • Return to it at consolidation and ask what evidence the class produced
      • Ask three students at random, mid-lesson, what they are learning

      Student actions

      • Read the goal aloud and say it back in their own words
      • Answer 'what are we learning?' without pointing at the board
    2. Days 4–6 — Add teacher-written criteria

      Five minutes per lesson

      Teacher actions

      • Write three to five 'I can…' statements beneath each goal
      • Do one mid-lesson check: 'point to the criterion you are working on'
      • Give one piece of feedback per student that names a criterion

      Student actions

      • Identify which criterion they are working on
      • Self-check against one criterion before submitting
    3. Days 7–8 — Co-construct with the class

      One twelve-minute block

      Teacher actions

      • Run one twelve-minute co-construction from two exemplars
      • Record student wording verbatim before tidying it into 'I can…' statements
      • Post the chart in the students' language and refer to it by their phrases

      Student actions

      • Analyse exemplars and name what made the strong one work
      • Agree on the final four or five criteria
    4. Days 9–10 — Hand the criteria to the students

      Ten minutes per lesson plus conference time

      Teacher actions

      • Run exit tickets referenced to criteria and group tomorrow's lesson from them
      • Teach one peer-feedback sentence frame that names a criterion
      • Hold three criteria-focused conferences of three minutes each
      • Write your rubric for the culminating task directly from the criteria

      Student actions

      • Self-assess against the full list and set one goal
      • Give a peer one criterion-specific piece of feedback

    Reflection

    • Could a student who walked in late tell a visitor what they are learning and how they will know they have learned it?
    • Is every criterion something I could watch a student do, or are some of them invisible states?
    • Did my feedback this week name a criterion, or was it general encouragement?
    • Are students using the chart without being told to?
    • Did I lower the goal for anyone when I should have adjusted the evidence instead?
    • Does my rubric use the same words as the chart on the wall?

    Challenges and solutions

    There is no time to co-construct criteria for every lesson
    You should not. Co-construct once per unit for the culminating kind of work, then reuse and refine that chart across the lessons that build toward it.
    Rotary or intermediate with five classes
    Write one goal and criteria set per lesson, not per class. Co-construct with your first period and let later classes critique and amend the chart — the amendment conversation is as valuable as the original.
    Students ignore the posted criteria
    They will until the criteria do something. Use them for the mid-lesson check, the exit ticket and the feedback in the same week, and the chart becomes a tool rather than a display.
    The criteria list keeps growing past five
    You have bundled two goals. Split the lesson, or move the task-management items off the learning chart entirely.
    Kindergarten students cannot read the criteria
    Use photographs, icons and the children's own recorded words. Say the criteria aloud during the block and name them in your documentation.
    Writing goals and criteria for every subject is exhausting
    Start in one subject and let it spread. When you are ready to go wider, generate a first draft from the expectation and edit it — editing a good draft takes a fraction of the time the blank page does.

    Ontario terms in this article

    Definitions, in Ministry language

    Learning Goals
    Learning goals are brief statements, written in student-friendly language, that describe what students are expected to know and be able to do by the end of a lesson or series of lessons. Learning Goals resources
    Differentiated Instruction
    Differentiated instruction adjusts content, process, product or learning environment in response to student readiness, interest and learning preference, while keeping the same curriculum expectations for the class. Differentiated Instruction resources
    Success Criteria
    Success criteria describe what successful attainment of a learning goal looks like. They are co-constructed with students where possible and used for descriptive feedback, self-assessment and peer assessment. Success Criteria resources
    Rubric
    An Ontario rubric describes achievement at Levels 1 to 4 against the four Achievement Chart categories, using the Ministry qualifiers limited, some, considerable and thorough. Rubric resources
    Growing Success (2010)
    Growing Success (2010) is Ontario's policy document for assessment, evaluation and reporting in Grades 1 to 12. It defines the Achievement Chart, the learning skills and work habits, and the role of professional judgement in determining a report card grade. Growing Success (2010) resources
    Assessment as Learning
    Assessment as learning positions the student as the assessor: they monitor their own progress against success criteria, set goals and adjust their approach with teacher support. Assessment as Learning resources

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Expectation to goal to criteria

    The whole chain, in eight Ontario subjects

    Each row shows the same three-step translation: a curriculum expectation written for teachers, a learning goal written for students, and the criteria that make the learning visible.

    Expectation

    Language: identify the main idea and supporting details in a variety of texts (Grade 4)

    Learning goal

    We are learning to find the big idea in a text and the details that support it.

    Success criteria

    I can name the big idea in my own words. I can find two details that support it. I can explain why those details matter.

    Expectation

    Mathematics: represent and compare fractions of a whole (Grade 3)

    Learning goal

    We are learning how fractions show equal parts of a whole.

    Success criteria

    I can divide a shape into equal parts. I can name the fraction. I can show it two ways. I can explain why the parts must be equal.

    Expectation

    Science: investigate forces acting on structures (Grade 5)

    Learning goal

    We are learning how forces can make a structure fail.

    Success criteria

    I can name the force. I can predict where it will fail and why. I can change one thing and test again.

    Expectation

    Social Studies: analyse different perspectives on an issue (Grade 6)

    Learning goal

    We are learning that people can look at the same event in very different ways.

    Success criteria

    I can describe the event with facts. I can explain two perspectives. I can support each one with evidence.

    Expectation

    The Arts: use elements of design to create a mood (Grade 6)

    Learning goal

    We are learning how an artist uses colour to create a mood.

    Success criteria

    I can name the mood I want. I can choose colours that create it. I can explain my choice as an artist.

    Expectation

    Health: apply strategies for managing stress (Grade 5)

    Learning goal

    We are learning to recognise the signs of stress in our own bodies.

    Success criteria

    I can name two signs I notice. I can name a strategy I could use. I can say when I would use it.

    Expectation

    Français : poser des questions pour clarifier sa compréhension (4e année)

    Learning goal

    Nous apprenons à poser des questions pour mieux comprendre.

    Success criteria

    Je peux poser une question complète. Je peux écouter sans interrompre. Je peux poser une question de suivi.

    Expectation

    Kindergarten: Problem Solving and Innovating

    Learning goal

    We are learning that we can test our ideas to find out if they work.

    Success criteria

    I can say my idea. I can try it. I can tell what happened. I can try a new way.

    Before and after

    Poor learning goal to improved learning goal

    Seven rewrites Ontario teachers can apply to their own plans tonight. The pattern in every row is the same: move from a topic, a task or a policy sentence to a statement of learning a student could read aloud.

    Fractions

    Why: A topic, not learning

    Improved: We are learning how fractions show equal parts of a whole.

    Today we will make a poster about the water cycle

    Why: An activity, not learning

    Improved: We are learning how water moves between the ground, the air and the clouds.

    Demonstrate an understanding of the processes involved in the water cycle

    Why: A curriculum expectation in teacher language

    Improved: We are learning why the water cycle keeps repeating.

    We are learning about Canada

    Why: Too broad to guide a lesson

    Improved: We are learning how the environment shapes the way people live.

    We are learning to read chapter four

    Why: A task with no learning attached

    Improved: We are learning to infer how a character feels from what they say and do.

    We are learning good writing

    Why: No observable evidence is possible

    Improved: We are learning to write an opinion piece that convinces a reader.

    We are learning to add, subtract, multiply and divide fractions

    Why: Four goals bundled into one

    Improved: We are learning to add fractions with the same denominator using a model.

    Before and after

    Poor success criteria to improved success criteria

    If a criterion describes an invisible state, a task instruction or three things at once, it cannot guide a student's work. These six rewrites cover the failures that appear most often on Ontario anchor charts.

    I can understand fractions

    Why: Understanding is invisible

    Improved: I can show one half in three different ways.

    I can do good work

    Why: No standard a student could apply

    Improved: I can check my work against the criteria and fix one thing before I hand it in.

    I can participate

    Why: Measures compliance, not learning

    Improved: I can add an idea that builds on what someone else said.

    I can utilise appropriate text features to locate information

    Why: Teacher language

    Improved: I can use headings and bold words to find what I need.

    I can put my name on my paper

    Why: A task instruction, not evidence of learning

    Improved: Move to your work-habits chart, not the criteria chart.

    I can solve the problem and show my work and explain it

    Why: Three criteria in one

    Improved: I can show my strategy with a model, numbers or words so someone else could follow it.

    Copy, adapt, teach

    25 ready-to-use Ontario learning goals

    Organised by grade band and subject, written in student-friendly language, and each one traceable to an Ontario curriculum expectation. Adapt the wording to your class — the point is the shape of the sentence, not the sentence itself.

    Kindergarten to Grade 2

    • Language — Reading

      We are learning to use the pictures and the letters to figure out a word we do not know.

    • Language — Writing

      We are learning to write sentences that tell our reader what happened first, next and last.

    • Language — Oral

      We are learning to listen carefully so we can add to someone else's idea.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning to use place value to explain what a number is worth.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning that we can show the same number in more than one way.

    • Science

      We are learning how living things change as they grow.

    • Kindergarten

      We are learning that we can test our ideas to find out if they work.

    • Health

      We are learning to name how our bodies feel when we are upset.

    Grades 3 to 5

    • Language — Reading

      We are learning to find the big idea in a text and the details that support it.

    • Language — Writing

      We are learning to write an opinion piece that convinces a reader.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning how fractions show equal parts of a whole.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning to choose a strategy that fits the numbers in the problem.

    • Science

      We are learning why some structures are stronger than others.

    • Science

      We are learning how forces can make a structure fail.

    • Social Studies

      We are learning how the environment shapes the way people live.

    • The Arts

      We are learning how an artist uses colour to create a mood.

    • Health

      We are learning to recognise the signs of stress in our own bodies.

    • French

      Nous apprenons à poser des questions pour mieux comprendre.

    Grades 6 to 8

    • Language — Media

      We are learning to notice whose voice is missing from a text.

    • Language — Reading

      We are learning to detect bias in a media text.

    • Language — Writing

      We are learning to anticipate what a reader might disagree with and answer it.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning to justify whether a relationship is linear.

    • Mathematics

      We are learning how the area of a triangle relates to the area of a parallelogram.

    • Science

      We are learning how a change in one part of a system affects the rest of it.

    • Social Studies / History

      We are learning that people can look at the same event in very different ways.

    • French

      Nous apprenons à utiliser des mots de transition pour relier nos idées.

    The bookmark section

    75 student-friendly success criteria

    Written the way students actually talk, grouped by strand. Choose three to five that match your learning goal, then improve them with your class — the version they help write is the version they will use.

    Reading and comprehension

    • I can retell what happened in order, using the characters' names.
    • I can find the sentence that shows what the author thinks.
    • I can make a prediction and say what made me think that.
    • I can explain a word I did not know using clues around it.
    • I can name the big idea in my own words.
    • I can find two details that support the big idea.
    • I can connect the text to something I already know.
    • I can ask a question the text did not answer.
    • I can say whose point of view the text is told from.
    • I can point to the part of the text that changed my thinking.

    Writing

    • I can state my opinion clearly in the first paragraph.
    • I can give reasons for my opinion.
    • I can support each reason with an example or a fact.
    • I can use linking words to connect my ideas.
    • I can end by restating my opinion in a new way.
    • I can organise my writing so my reader can follow it.
    • I can choose words that create the feeling I want.
    • I can vary how my sentences begin.
    • I can reread my writing and fix one thing before I hand it in.
    • I can use the criteria to decide what to improve next.

    Oral communication and collaboration

    • I can add an idea that builds on what someone else said.
    • I can ask a question that helps our group move forward.
    • I can explain my thinking so someone else could follow it.
    • I can disagree respectfully and give a reason.
    • I can listen to the whole idea before I answer.
    • I can summarise what my partner said before I add to it.
    • I can use the vocabulary from our unit when I talk.
    • I can give my group member a next step, not just praise.

    Mathematics

    • I can divide a shape into equal parts.
    • I can name the fraction using the number of parts.
    • I can show the same fraction in two different ways.
    • I can explain why the parts have to be equal.
    • I can show my strategy with a model, numbers or words.
    • I can check whether my answer is reasonable.
    • I can use place value language to explain which number is greater.
    • I can choose a strategy that fits the numbers in the question.
    • I can explain why my strategy works, not just what I did.
    • I can find my mistake and say what caused it.
    • I can try a second strategy and compare it to my first.
    • I can use a math word from our word wall correctly.

    Science, inquiry and problem solving

    • I can name the force acting on my structure.
    • I can predict what will happen and say why.
    • I can change one thing and test again.
    • I can explain what my change did.
    • I can record what I observed, not what I hoped for.
    • I can use a labelled diagram to show my design.
    • I can name one thing I would do differently next time.
    • I can ask a question that could be tested.
    • I can use evidence from my test to support my conclusion.

    Social studies, history and geography

    • I can describe the event using facts.
    • I can explain two different perspectives on it.
    • I can say what might cause each perspective.
    • I can use evidence from a source to support what I say.
    • I can tell whether my source is reliable and say why.
    • I can use a map to explain where and why something happened.
    • I can explain how a decision affected different groups differently.

    The arts, health and self-assessment

    • I can use contrast to draw the viewer's eye.
    • I can explain the choice I made as an artist.
    • I can give feedback that names a criterion.
    • I can name a strategy that helps me calm my body.
    • I can name which criterion I have met and show my evidence.
    • I can name the criterion I am still working on.
    • I can set one goal for my next piece of work.
    • I can explain how my work improved from my first attempt.
    • I can ask for the help I actually need.

    Making learning visible is the whole point

    Learning goals and success criteria are not planning templates to be completed and filed. They are the difference between a class that finishes activities and a class that knows what it is learning. They give students clarity, they make feedback specific, they make assessment defensible, and they keep every lesson pointed at learning rather than at the task in front of it.

    Start smaller than you think you should. One subject, one clear goal a day, four criteria written with your class from two exemplars. Within three weeks students will start using the chart without being told to, and your feedback will get shorter and sharper because you will finally have something precise to point at.

    Ontario Curriculum AI exists for the part that eats your evenings: turning an expectation into a student-friendly goal, drafting criteria you can refine with your class, building the three-part lesson around them, writing the rubric in the same language, producing the differentiated version for the students who need another entry point, and — in December and June — turning a year of criteria-referenced evidence into report card comments. The professional judgement stays exactly where it belongs, with you. The blank page does not have to be part of planning.

    0% read · about 28 min left

    Keep going

    Growing SuccessGrowing Success GuideAssessment for, as and of learning, and where learning goals and criteria sit in policy.JournalOntario Assessment StrategiesTriangulated evidence — observations, conversations and products — in daily practice.JournalOntario Diagnostic Assessments25 diagnostics that tell you where students are before you write the goal.JournalThe First 10 Days of SchoolWhere co-construction fits in the opening days of the Ontario school year.JournalOntario Classroom SetupAnchor chart space, visibility and the routines that make criteria usable.JournalOntario Back-to-School ChecklistEverything to prepare in late August, including your first unit's goals.Journal35 First Week ActivitiesCommunity-building tasks that make excellent first co-construction opportunities.Free ToolkitBack-to-School ToolkitEvery September planning and assessment resource in one place.AI ToolLesson and Unit PlanningThree-part lessons, unit plans and long-range plans mapped to Ontario expectations.AI ToolAssessment GeneratorAssessments, exit tickets and success criteria built on the Achievement Chart.AI ToolRubric BuilderLevels 1–4 rubrics written in the language of your success criteria.AI ToolStudent Feedback GeneratorDescriptive feedback that names a criterion, a strength and a next step.AI ToolReport Card CommentsWhere a year of criteria-referenced evidence eventually lands.AI ToolDifferentiation ToolsScaffolded and extended criteria for the same shared learning goal.AI ToolIEP BuilderMeasurable goals and accommodations aligned to your classroom criteria.AI ToolParent CommunicationExplaining a student's next step to families in the language of the criteria.AI ToolTeacher ResetA guided milestone sequence for the start of the Ontario school year.Ontario CurriculumOntario Curriculum HubOverall and specific expectations by grade and subject, ready to unbundle.

    Apply this to my classroom™

    Apply "Learning Goals vs Success Criteria: The Complete Ontario Teacher Guide" this week

    Choose one idea from this article and put it into a lesson you are already teaching.

    Time
    About 24 minutes
    Steps
    5
    You will finish with
    One concrete piece of classroom work, finished rather than planned.

    Opens a guided workshop. Your progress and reflections stay private on this device.

    Adapt This for My Classroom™

    Rewrite this article for the class you actually teach

    Journal will take what you have just read and turn it into a plan sized for your grades, your subjects and the students in your room — with the differentiation moves already worked out.

    Tell Journal about your classroom once and every article can adapt to it.

    Your profile stays on your device. Only the general shape of your class is sent to generate the plan — never a student name. Everything here is a draft for your professional judgment.

    Everything below is part of the same Ontario knowledge base — guides, tools and templates that build on this article.

    • Reviewed by Ontario educators
    • Updated on a 90-day review cycle
    • Built in Ontario
    • Growing Success aligned
    • Privacy-first — no student data stored
    • Evidence-informed

    Reviewed each August before the Ontario school year

    Ontario Curriculum AI Newsletter

    Get New Ontario Planning and Assessment Resources First

    • Exclusive editable templates
    • New AI tools as they ship
    • Ontario teacher guides
    • Free downloads
    • Seasonal resources for each reporting period

    Get Ontario Reporting & Planning Updates

    New tools, reporting-season guides, and policy insights for Ontario educators.

    No spam. Ontario-focused updates only. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Ready to get these hours back?

    Everything in this article can be drafted for your grade, subject and class in a single sitting. You still apply your professional judgment — the tool just removes the blank page.

    • Built for Ontario, not adapted to it
    • Growing Success aligned language
    • No student data required
    • Canadian hosting, PIPEDA aligned
    • Free plan available

    Editorial information

    Reviewed
    August 13, 2026
    Last updated
    August 13, 2026
    Reading time
    28 minutes
    Difficulty
    foundational
    Ontario grade levels
    Kindergarten to Grade 8 (adaptable for secondary)
    Applicable subjects
    All subjects
    Evidence level
    Ontario Ministry policy (Growing Success)
    Editorial confidence
    High — verified against current Ministry documents

    Every draft produced by Ontario Curriculum AI is a starting point. Ontario educators remain responsible for professional judgment, board policy and the accuracy of anything sent home.