Skip to content
    How toYear 2 of Kindergarten to Grade 2· Reviewed every 3–6 months

    What happens when a student is below benchmark on an Ontario reading screener?

    Turn a below-benchmark screening result into the right instructional response, documented properly.

    Ontario source-backedLast verified Next review Policy-sensitive

    Short answer

    What happens when a student is below benchmark on an Ontario reading screener?

    A below-benchmark result starts instruction, not paperwork. The student receives more explicit, systematic teaching of the specific skill that was flagged, with closer progress monitoring, and is screened again by the middle of March. It is not an automatic special education referral, and screening on its own does not decide whether a student needs those services.

    Ontario context

    • Policy/Program Memorandum 168 places the follow-up in instruction: a flag routes the student into more intensive, evidence-based teaching and closer monitoring.
    • Learning for All (2013) is the ministry resource describing the tiered approach Ontario schools use for prevention and intervention. It is ministry guidance rather than a memorandum, so the tier structure is the provincial model rather than a legal rule.
    • The second mandated screening in March applies to students who did not meet the benchmark the first time, so the flagged group is exactly the group whose progress is re-checked.
    • Boards differ in who delivers the extra support, in what block, and how often progress is re-measured.

    What is actually required

    Ontario policy
    • A below-benchmark screening result must lead to more intensive, evidence-based reading instruction and closer progress monitoring rather than an automatic special education referral.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Policy/Program Memorandum 168: Reading Instruction and Early Reading Screening

    • Screening must not be the sole method used to determine whether a student requires special education programs or services.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Policy/Program Memorandum 168: Reading Instruction and Early Reading Screening

    • Parents and guardians must be informed in a timely way where a student will receive more intensive support.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Policy/Program Memorandum 168: Reading Instruction and Early Reading Screening

    • Who delivers the additional instruction, when it is timetabled and how often progress is re-measured is a board decision.

      Ontario Ministry of Education — Policy/Program Memorandum 168: Reading Instruction and Early Reading Screening

      Your board or school may have additional procedures.

    The first two weeks after a flag

    • Read the sub-scores. 'Below benchmark' is a summary; the teaching decision lives in which sub-test the student missed.
    • Add a short daily block on that specific skill, in a small group of students with the same profile where possible.
    • Set a monitoring probe you can run in under three minutes and use it weekly, so you see movement in four weeks rather than in March.
    • Tell the family what you are doing in plain language, before they hear a score from their child.

    When special education involvement is the right call

    • When targeted instruction has run long enough to show a trend and the trend is flat, bring the data to your school team.
    • Bring the probe record, not an impression. Four weekly data points and a description of the instruction is a stronger case than any single screening score.
    • Screening evidence is one input among several; the school team weighs classroom evidence, work samples and observation alongside it.

    What a flag does and does not trigger

    More intensive, explicit instruction in the flagged skill

    Provincially set
    Yes
    Board or school decision
    How it is staffed and timetabled

    Closer progress monitoring

    Provincially set
    Yes
    Board or school decision
    Which probe and how often

    Re-screening by the middle of March

    Provincially set
    Yes
    Board or school decision
    Exact date inside the window

    Special education referral

    Provincially set
    No — not automatic
    Board or school decision
    Local school team process

    Provincial column reflects PPM 168. The tiered structure around it comes from Learning for All, which is ministry guidance.

    What strong practice looks like

    Professional practice
    • Group by the skill that was flagged, not by the overall score. Two students below benchmark can need opposite lessons.
    • Keep the intervention short and daily. Twenty minutes four times a week beats an hour once.
    • Write down what you changed instructionally on the day you changed it — that record is what makes the later conversation credible.

    What this looks like in practice

    A Grade 1 student flagged on non-word reading

    Instead of: Wait for the March re-screen to see if it resolves.

    Start daily targeted decoding practice within the week, monitor weekly with a short non-word probe, and bring four weeks of data to the school team if the line is flat.

    Why it works: The flag exists to trigger teaching now; the March screening is a checkpoint on the teaching, not the starting gun.

    A Year 2 Kindergarten student flagged on phoneme segmenting

    Short daily oral segmenting in a group of three, with a weekly informal check, and a conversation with the family about what you are practising.

    Why it works: The response matches the flagged skill and keeps the family informed as the support intensifies.

    Practical suggestions

    Practical classroom suggestion
    • Build the follow-up groups the same week the results land; a two-week delay costs a fifth of the intervention window.
    • Keep one page per flagged student: skill, instruction, dates, probe results.
    • Ask your special education teacher to look at the class profile early, before any individual referral question arises.

    Common mistakes

    Treating a screening flag as an identification.

    Instead: It flags risk in a narrow skill band. Identification is a separate process with its own evidence.

    Sending the score home with no explanation.

    Instead: Explain what was screened, what you are teaching differently, and when you will look again.

    Running a generic reading group for everyone who was flagged.

    Instead: Group by flagged skill so the instruction is actually targeted.

    The takeaway

    A screening flag is an instruction trigger with a March checkpoint. The professional record that matters is not the score but the dated evidence of what you taught differently and what changed.

    Ontario sources

    Every source we cite, with its verification date, is listed in the public source index.

    Was this answer helpful?

    Prepared by Ontario Curriculum AI.

    Last reviewed 2026-08-18 · next review 2027-02-18

    Ontario Curriculum AI supports professional work. Educators retain professional judgement for all assessment, evaluation and reporting decisions.